For a long time, most of what people “knew” about nonmonogamy came from stereotypes: it’s a phase, it’s a sign of commitment issues, it always ends badly. Over the past couple of decades, though, relationship scientists have started studying consensual nonmonogamy (CNM) directly. The picture that’s emerging is more interesting, and more reassuring, than the stereotypes suggest.
Here’s an overview of what the research has found so far and, just as important, what it can’t tell us yet.

It’s more common than you might think
CNM isn’t a tiny fringe. In a 2017 study by a team that included Amy Moors and Justin Garcia, which drew on two large national samples of single adults in the United States, roughly one in five participants said they had been in a consensually nonmonogamous relationship at some point in their lives. The share of people in one at any given moment is smaller, but having tried it is clearly not rare.
The stigma is real, and surprisingly broad
One of the most consistent findings is that people judge nonmonogamous relationships harshly. In studies led by Terri Conley at the University of Michigan, participants rated monogamous relationships more favorably than consensually nonmonogamous ones across the board, including on qualities that have nothing to do with relationships at all. Researchers describe this as a “halo effect” around monogamy: once people know a relationship is monogamous, they tend to assume all kinds of other good things about the people in it.
That matters because stigma has real costs. It shapes how people are treated by friends, family and professionals, and it pushes many people to hide their relationships. Overcoming that stigma is one of the topics in our free Open Smarter masterclass.
Relationship quality looks broadly similar
The question most people really want answered: are nonmonogamous relationships less happy? So far, the evidence says not necessarily. A 2015 review by Justin Rubel and Anthony Bogaert looked across the existing studies and found no consistent differences in psychological well-being or relationship quality between people in consensually nonmonogamous relationships and people in monogamous ones.
Later comparisons by Conley, Moors and their colleagues have broadly echoed that conclusion, though results can differ between types of CNM. That’s one reason researchers now try to study polyamory, swinging and open relationships separately rather than lumping them together.
Some studies have even found lower average jealousy among polyamorous participants than among monogamous ones. It’s an intriguing result, but it’s hard to know which way it runs: does nonmonogamy reduce jealousy, or are less jealous people simply more drawn to it? (If jealousy is your sticking point, our piece on compersion looks at the other side of that coin.)
Openly nonmonogamous people tend to practice safer sex than cheaters
A common assumption is that nonmonogamy automatically means more sexual health risk. The research suggests the bigger risk may lie somewhere else. In a 2012 study, Conley and colleagues found that people who were cheating on supposedly monogamous partners were less likely to practice safer sex, such as using condoms consistently, than people in openly nonmonogamous relationships.
The takeaway isn’t that nonmonogamy is risk-free. More partners does mean thinking carefully about sexual health. But openness makes it possible to talk about testing and barriers and to agree on them, which is exactly what secrecy prevents. It’s why sexual health gets its own section in our guide to relationship agreements.
A second partner doesn’t have to take away from the first
One worry about polyamory is that partners compete, so that getting your needs met elsewhere will drain your existing relationship. A 2014 study of polyamorous people by Mitchell, Bartholomew and Cobb looked at exactly this. How well people’s needs were met by a partner predicted their satisfaction with that partner, but needs met by a second partner didn’t come at the cost of satisfaction with the first. In other words, partners seemed to add to each other rather than substitute for each other.
Primary and secondary relationships feel different
Research by Rhonda Balzarini and colleagues compared the “primary” and “secondary” relationships of people practicing hierarchical polyamory. Primary relationships tended to involve more investment, commitment and acceptance from friends and family, while secondary relationships involved more secrecy and stigma, and a larger share of time spent on sex. That’s useful for anyone navigating hierarchy: the extra weight a primary partnership carries is real, and so is the pressure secondary partners can feel.
Kids in polyamorous families
Sociologist Elisabeth Sheff followed polyamorous families with children over many years. In her work, the children generally did well and often benefited from having more adults around to give them attention and support. The challenges she described had less to do with polyamory itself than with stigma, and with kids losing touch with adults they’d grown attached to when a relationship ended.
What we still don’t know
This is a young field, and it’s worth reading every finding with its limits in mind:
- Self-selected samples. Many studies recruit through nonmonogamous communities online, and people who are happy with their relationships may be more likely to volunteer.
- Snapshots, not stories. Most studies measure people at a single point in time. They can’t easily show how relationships change over the years, or how many people tried CNM and went back to monogamy.
- Narrow demographics. Participants have often been disproportionately white, well educated and Western.
- Mixed categories. Early studies sometimes grouped polyamory, swinging and open relationships together, even though they work quite differently.
What this means for you
The research doesn’t say nonmonogamy is better than monogamy, or that it suits everyone. It says something more modest and more useful: when it’s consensual and handled with care, nonmonogamy isn’t inherently less healthy or less loving. What seems to matter most is the same thing that matters in any relationship: honesty, communication, and whether the structure fits the actual people in it.
So the better question isn’t “is nonmonogamy good or bad?” but “what’s the right relationship style for me?” If you’re ready to start exploring that with someone you love, our guide on how to bring up nonmonogamy with your partner is a good next step.


