
Every couple that opens up makes agreements. The question is whether those agreements live in a shared document or in two different memories that slowly drift apart. “I thought we said…” is one of the most common ways a fight starts in nonmonogamous relationships, and most of the time nobody is lying. They simply remember the conversation differently.
Putting your agreements in writing won’t make your relationship bulletproof. But it forces you to be specific, gives you something to come back to, and makes renegotiating much easier. Here’s what to include, what to leave out, and how to write it together.
Agreements, not rules
First, a distinction worth making. Rules tend to restrict what a partner may do, and they’re often written from fear: “You can’t sleep over,” “You can’t see them more than once a month.” Agreements describe what each person commits to and why, and they assume that anyone involved can bring them back to the table.
The difference matters because rules about your partner’s other relationships also affect people who never agreed to them. A good test for anything you write down: would this still feel fair if I were the new person on the receiving end?
What to put in writing
Not every couple needs every section below, but these are the areas that most often cause misunderstandings when nobody has spelled them out.
Your structure, and why you’re doing this
Start with the big picture. Are you open sexually, open to romance, swinging as a couple? (If you’re unsure of the terms, see polyamory vs. open relationship vs. swinging.) Then each write a few sentences about what you hope to get out of it. When things get hard, rereading your original reasons is surprisingly grounding.
Sexual health
- When you’ll use condoms or other barriers, and with whom.
- How often you’ll each get tested for STIs, and how you’ll share results with partners and metamours.
- What happens after a possible exposure or a broken condom: who gets told, and how quickly.
- Contraception, and what you’d do about an unplanned pregnancy.
- Whether, and how, anyone can become “fluid bonded” (having sex without barriers) with a new partner.
It’s worth talking these through with a healthcare provider, too, so your testing schedule and prevention options fit your actual situation.
Disclosure
How much do you each want to know, and when? Some people want a heads-up before a date; others prefer to hear afterward; some want no details at all. Agree on whether you’ll share names, photos and what actually happened, and remember that these preferences can be different for each of you.
Time and scheduling
Time is where most practical conflicts show up. Cover how many evenings a week can go to other partners, overnights, trips, and protected days like anniversaries, birthdays and holidays. A shared calendar removes a lot of friction.
Shared spaces and shared life
Can other partners come to your home? Stay the night? Use your bed? What about mutual friends, social media, or meeting family? These are the agreements people most often forget to make until the situation is already happening.
Who’s off-limits
Many couples agree to avoid exes, close friends, coworkers or neighbors, at least at first. Write down any specific names or categories so there’s no gray area.
Privacy and outness
Who knows you’re nonmonogamous? How will you introduce each other’s partners? How will you protect the privacy of metamours who may not be out themselves?
When feelings change
If your arrangement is meant to be sexual only, what happens if someone catches feelings? Agree to tell each other early rather than pretending it isn’t happening. (And if you’d like to feel more than just “okay” about a partner’s new connection, read about compersion.) If you’re considering a veto, where one partner can ask the other to end an outside relationship, discuss it carefully: it gives one person a lot of power over someone who isn’t part of the agreement.
Check-ins, pauses and reviews
Decide how often you’ll check in (weekly is common at first), how either of you can ask to slow down or pause, and when you’ll review the whole document. A date at the top of the page and a planned review a few months out keep it alive.
What to leave out
- Rules about feelings. “You’re not allowed to fall in love” can’t be enforced. Agree on what you’ll do if it happens instead.
- Anything agreed to under pressure. If one of you is saying yes just to keep the peace, the agreement won’t hold.
- Agreements that require surveillance. If the only way to keep a rule is to check your partner’s phone, it isn’t a workable rule.
How to write it together
Brainstorm separately first, so neither of you simply adopts the other’s list. Then compare notes, starting with what you already agree on. Use plain language and short sentences. Mark anything that’s a “for now” item. Keep the document somewhere you can both access and edit, and date each version.
If you’re still at the stage of raising the idea, start with how to bring up nonmonogamy with your partner. A written agreement works best as the result of good conversations, not as a replacement for them.
When an agreement gets broken
At some point, it will happen. Someone forgets to mention a date, a check-in gets skipped, a boundary turns out to be fuzzier than you thought. Separate honest mistakes from deliberate breaches. For mistakes, talk about what happened, repair, and adjust the wording. Deliberate breaches are a bigger trust problem and deserve slower, more serious conversations, sometimes with outside help.
Either way, treat your agreements as a living document. The goal isn’t a perfect contract. It’s a shared, up-to-date picture of what you’re building together, and a practical way to live “outside the box” while staying safe, sane and loved. That’s the question at the heart of the free Open Smarter masterclass.


